The myth of Japan’s "lost decade"?

From Urbaneconomics comes this.   The take away is that Japan’s economic performance is not as bad as represented when per working age productivity is examined, but an aging population slowed aggregate growth.  The issue of aging population will be one for most industrialized nations. 

One additional thing to consider is what does this say for the success of Japan’s stimulus programs.  These programs have generally been dismissed as not very successful, but that may be an unwarranted assumption.

Daniel Gros provides an interesting twist to the conventional wisdom that Japan suffered a "lost decade" in the first decade of the millennium, posting annualized real GDP growth of just 0.6% (to US’s 1.7%) – demography!
He argues that instead of blindly comparing the overall GDP growth rates, a more meaningful standard for comparison will be the growth of income per head of the working-age population (WAP)(which represents an economy’s productive potential). And a comparison reveals,

"When one looks at GDP/WAP (defined as population aged 20-60), one gets a surprising result: Japan has actually done better than the US or most European countries over the last decade. The reason is simple: Japan’s overall growth rates have been quite low, but growth was achieved despite a rapidly shrinking working-age population.
The difference between Japan and the US is instructive here: in terms of overall GDP growth, it was about one percentage point, but larger in terms of the annual WAP growth rates – more than 1.5 percentage points, given that the US working-age population grew by 0.8%, whereas Japan’s has been shrinking at about the same rate.
Another indication that Japan has fully used its potential is that the unemployment rate has been constant over the last decade. By contrast, the US unemployment rate has almost doubled, now approaching 10%. One might thus conclude that the US should take Japan as an example not of stagnation, but of how to squeeze maximum growth from limited potential."

Assuming the working population as the measure of the country’s productive capacity, it can be safely concluded that Japan has been successful in squeezing out the most from its shrinking working population. Since its working age population will continue to shrink by about 1% per year, Japan’s continued relative decline is to be expected. Germany and Italy too are likely to follow in Japan’s footsteps. Prof Gros attributes the current strength of the German economy partly due to the temporary demographic stabilization in the 2005-15 period.
In many respects, Japan’s current problems can be a reliable precursor for many of the other developed economies, including the US. The stand-out performance of the US economy over the past two decades, in comparison to the weakness in Japan and Europe, conceals the demographic advantage enjoyed by the US. In this context, Prof Gros raises concerns about the long-term growth prospects of developed economies, given their unfavorable demographic trends

"Slow growth in Japan over the last decade was due not to insufficiently aggressive macroeconomic policies, but to an unfavorable demographic trend. Second, a further slowdown in rich countries’ growth rates appears inevitable, given that even in the more dynamic countries the growth rates of the working-age population is declining. In the less dynamic ones, like Japan, Germany, and Italy, near-stagnation seems inevitable."

Add to Technorati Favoritesalt

The myth of Japan’s "lost decade"? (gulzar)
Sun, 09 Jan 2011 00:09:00 GMT


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s